Dennis the Constitutional Peasant, from "Monty Python and the Holy Grail" (1975), directed by Terry Gilliam and Terry Jones

Hard to pick just one scene from Python's oeuvre, but I think this is the most sharply scripted, with a hilarious parody of Marxist-anarchist critiques. Or is it Weberian? Magne Flemmen comments online: "Rather than Marxian concepts, I've used [this scene in classes] to illustrate Weber's distinction between charismatic and rational-legal authority. Upon being asked how he became King, Arthur offers a classical charismatic account: He has been appointed by God, with the Lady of the Lake offering him Excalibur. This is challenged by the peasant, who offers a typical rational-legal critique: 'Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony'. To my mind, this is the perfect example of the distinction between the two types of authority: the anarchist peasant's critque is almost ideal-typical of (legitimations of) rational-legal authority under democracy." (I just took all the fun out of it, didn't I?) With Michael Palin as Dennis, the recently deceased Terry Jones as his mum; Graham Chapman as King Arthur and Terry Gilliam as his coconut-clapping sidekick, Patsy.

---

Video and text excerpts posted on this blog are protected under the "fair use" provisions of sections 17 U.S.C. §106 and 17 U.S.C. §106A. This material is posted for educational, critical, and commentary purposes only. It is not monetized in any way, and no copyright is asserted over the posted material.